Drop in Keyword Rankings and How to Fix It

Picture this: you’re flying high on Google rankings, enjoying a coveted SERP position. However, for seemingly no reason, your website drops down a few places on page one rankings, maybe even several pages. Clearly, your Google search ranking went down – not good, right? 

Commonly referred to as ‘Google keywords ranking’, rankings fluctuate and drop all the time. Even the top ranking sites see frequent position changes; it’s a constant battle to stay on page one. 

Still, when your website falls down the SERP ranking page, it’s disheartening. It means fewer site visitors and conversions and, therefore, reduced profits. Your kneejerk response? Fix it. Right now. However, that’s where we say, wait, hold your horses. 

First, you must figure out why your site ranking dropped and then fix the problem. Is the ranking dip down to a failed or faulty SEO strategy? Has Google changed its algorithm yet again? Or is your SEO tool malfunctioning? This guide covers these questions and more! 

Tip: Our professional CRO Services can help you boost conversions after a site ranking drops! 

How Do I Check My Site Ranking? 

Knowing how to check your website’s ranking position is the first vital step you need to take. So, before asking, ‘why is my site ranking poorly?’ you’ll need to know how to check Google ranking. ‘How do I check my ranking?’ and ‘how do I check my website ranking?’ are queries we see daily. To answer those questions, these are some of the best Google ranker tools: 

• Google Search Console: In Google Search Console, select the ‘Search Results’ tab under ‘Performance’. Next, click ‘Queries’ to see the search terms your website ranks for.  
• Google Analytics: You can also connect Google Analytics to Google Search Console to see your website rankings. 
• Ahrefs: Input your website, and this rank checker tool shows which keywords your website ranks for, as well as the position, search volumes, and keyword difficulty. Ahrefs also tells you if your site ranks for Google’s extras, like featured snippets, site links, the ‘People Also Ask’ section, and more. 

• SEMrush: This organic research tool lets you type in your website and check which keywords it ranks for. The report also shows you your ranking position, keyword difficulty, and search volume for each keyword. 

Though there are more, these tools are familiar favourites for checking keyword and website page ranks. 

Check Your Google Ranking Actually Dropped 

So, your Google keywords ranking went south, and your website with it. However, first, assess whether there is a SERP ranking page drop issue going on. Occasionally, a rankings change isn’t happening, even though it looks like you’ve dropped down the SERP ranking page.  

Perhaps your search rankings tracker hasn’t been localised, or maybe Google is performing one of its notorious ranking experiments. On the other hand, your website tracking tool could be experiencing technical troubles. If a single tool is exhibiting weird results, it might be an issue with the tool, not your website. 

As such, check your website, its Google keyword rankings, and other metrics on several different site rankers, such as Google Analytics, Ahrefs, SEMrush, and others, to determine if your organic search traffic has indeed dropped. While it’s normal for the chart to fluctuate, a huge dip that doesn’t rise again signals a problem with your website and SEO.  

After confirming your website ranking has dropped, you’ll need to diagnose and fix the cause. With this in mind, the next sections cover common reasons for a website’s drop in rankings (and what you can do about each one). 

Is Google’s Algorithm Broken? 

Ask yourself this: is Google’s algorithm down? Your Google keywords ranking decrease could be due to Google’s ranking algorithm messing up instead of an SEO ranking drop on your part. 

Before making rash decisions after noticing a drop in your website’s ranking, check your SEO rankings over the next day or two. If they’re still low afterwards, it’s time to check for potential SEO issues.  

External Google Ranking Factors 

A common external Google search engine ranking factor is one you can’t really control: bank holiday weekends and seasonal holidays (like Christmas) can temporarily impact your Google keywords ranking. 

It’s Not Christmas, and Google’s Algorithm Isn’t Broken – So Why Has My Website Ranking Dropped? 

Once you’ve confirmed your Google website ranking has dropped (and it’s not because Google’s algorithm is playing games or because Santa’s coming to town), it’s time to take another step to find the root cause of your Google search ranking drop. The drop could be due to changes or fluctuations in metrics or an issue with your site.  

Section 1: Check Your Website 

First, go to your website and check that everything looks okay. If something’s wrong with its appearance, therein lies an issue. 

Also, check if: 

• Your domain’s name expired 

• Your hosting has expired 
• There’s a problem at your web host’s end with it not displaying your site 

If none of these issues apply, you’ll need to check site problems, metrics, Google keyword rankings, and any recent changes to your website. Website rankings drops could occur when a site’s performance, SEO, data, or a critical metric suddenly changes. These include: 

1. Keyword Fluctuations 

To rank a website, search engines use relevant keywords – and sites ranking higher than others tend to feature the right amount of said relevant keywords.  

A Google rank for keyword use may change depending on the search volume of that word. In some cases, Google keywords ranking fluctuations could cause your Google website ranking to plummet. For instance, your site might drop when one of your primary keywords suddenly declines in popularity, so you’ll need to replace it with higher-ranking keywords.  

Whatever the reason for keyword fluctuations, use rank tracker tools regularly to identify keyword ranking changes.  

2. Title Changes 

Changes to your title tag can impact your Google search ranking. It’s one of the most basic page rank drop causes because headings tell search engines what a page’s content is all about. If you’ve changed any titles recently, that could be why your site has gone down the search engine page ranks. 

3. Meta Description Changes 

Although meta descriptions don’t typically affect search rankings that much, they can affect your site’s click-through rate (CTR). 

4. Internal Link Changes 

Changes to your website’s internal linking structure can also impact your SEO and send your site lower in the SERPs – so check if any modifications were made to these links. 

5. Page Speed Issues 

Page speed is a major Google website ranking factor. Users are impatient; they don’t like slow websites they have to wait for to load. If your website’s too slow (literally, a second or two delay is all it takes), people click away, and your bounce rate skyrockets. Google acknowledges this when it tries to rank a website, penalising those that function like snails.  

Tip: Check your website loading speed for desktops and mobile devices using Google PageSpeed Insights. It also gives suggestions to help you fix speed issues. 

6. Robots.txt File Not Working or Missing 

When troubleshooting SEO rankings drop, this technical corner of the process is often overlooked. However, it’s a vital piece of the site ranking puzzle; this little file tells search engine crawlers which URLs crawlers can access on your website. Therefore, don’t forget to check your site’s robots.txt file and ensure pages are being crawled.   

Tip: Our full guide on robots.txt can help you with this step! 

7. Backend Changes

Sometimes, website changes aren’t so obvious, especially when they occur at your site’s backend. Have you recently: 

• Added new web pages? 

• Added new site themes? 
• Installed new plugins? 
• Updated existing plugins? 
• Changed URL structure? 
• Moved your website to a new domain or host? 

• Added a noindex tag or selected an option preventing webpage crawling and indexing? 
• Changed canonical URLs? (When using a 301 redirect, your XML sitemaps and tags may have been updated) 

These backend changes could affect your Google rankings, webpage crawling, and page indexing on SERPs, so don’t forget to check these. 

Tip: Check our XML sitemaps guide and our post on canonical tags for more information on those latter two bullet points 

Section 2: Check Google Search Console for Errors or Penalties 

Google automatically notifies you if crawl errors are found when its bots crawl pages to rank a website – think of these as invisible Google ranker minions inspecting your site and its pages for strengths and weaknesses.  

Additionally, Google’s human reviewers could have flagged your site for manual action. Google gives manual action penalties if a website doesn’t meet quality guidelines; if yours has one, you’ll find them at the top of the site report. A Google penalty can affect your Google search ranking, so checking for any and acting on them fast is vital. 

Section 3: Has Google Updated Recently? 

Google updates multiple times annually. Check when your Google site ranking dropped and see if there was a Google update around that time. If so, that’s probably the reason for your site’s ranking change. However, Google algorithm updates usually take time to cause any drops in Google rankings, so it could be that an update occurred a while before your website dropped. 

Still, it’s best to check if SERP fluctuations result from an algorithm change and improve your website according to the changes. For instance, an update could’ve targeted your site keyword ranking or something a little more complex, like backlinks. In the past, Google’s Medic update targeted niches like health and finance – Google’s quality guidelines hold them to higher standards. Many websites in these fields suffered dramatic drops in Google positions and had to change SEO accordingly. 

Section 4: Discover What Caused Your Google Site Ranking to Drop (and When) 

Okay, so you’ve ruled out the rank drop issues in the previous sections. Next, it’s time to dissect the problem and identify exactly what dropped. 

Questions to answer: 

• Are all your web pages affected? I.e., your entire website? 
• Did just a few pages drop, not all? 

• Or is just one page affected? 
• How about keywords? Which keywords are you targeting, which ones dropped, and when did they begin to drop? 

You can answer these questions by checking your analytics tool of choice, such as Google Analytics, SEMrush, or Ahrefs. Once you’ve acquired data and answered the questions above, you can conduct research to find out your website’s ranking drop cause.  

Touching on topics mentioned in earlier sections, use your research to answer: 

• Are there any notifications in Google Search Console? 
• Did you change your SEO tactics or stop performing any work you’d been doing previously?  
• Did Google release any updates around the time your site dropped? 

• Is your company seasonal? For instance, a summer clothing store might get more traffic in spring and summer than in the middle of winter.  

Uncovering the answer to these queries can help you fathom what might have caused your web pages, entire websites, or keywords’ rankings to drop. 

Section 5: Is Your Competitor Outranking You? 

It could well be that your site didn’t drop – another site just outperformed it in terms of SEO. Look at your competitors’ methods and see how their strategies differ from yours – even the smallest difference could impact search engine rankings. In some cases, it could be as simple as your rivals utilising higher Google keyword search ranking opportunities, which you can fix by adding said keywords to your content.  

Whatever the case, you must check the competition regularly and verify which changes in their tactics enabled them to overtake your site ranking in the SERPs. 

Use these points to verify if your competitors have affected your site ranking position: 

• How much content does your competitor have? Is their blog ranking higher than yours for content quality and keywords? Quality content improves rankings (and as a Blog Writing Agency, we can help with this fundamental ranking factor) 
• How many pages does your rival’s website have? The more high-quality pages, the higher a website may rank – and if there are more than on your site, say bye-bye to your ranking position. 
• Does the competition’s website have a better UX (user experience)? Google rewards sites with top-quality UX.  
• Does your rival have a higher volume of quality links and backlinks? 

You can answer these questions with an analytics tool. For example, you can use Ahrefs Domain Comparison to compare your URL and your competitors’ URLs. This function lets you check the above factors to check if the competition’s on-page SEO and backlink profile are doing better than yours. 

Tip: As an Enterprise SEO Agency, our specialists here at Click Intelligence always keep your business ahead of its competitors! 

Section 6: How’s Your Backlink Profile? 

On the topic of backlinks, link building forms a strong part of a website’s SEO – and it could be that a link referring to your site or a lost backlink has impacted your site’s ranking position. 

Tip: We can perform a full Backlink Audit for you and improve your backlink profile’s health! 

1. Look for Any Lost Backlinks 

If you lose a backlink from a website with a high Domain Authority, this can result in a dip in your Google rankings. You can use tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs to check your backlink profile and see if and when you lost any important links (or even a collection of links) and which sites those links came from. If you lost any links, it might be worth contacting the websites they were on to see if you can get them re-established. 

2. Say No to Spammy, Unnatural Backlinks 

Sure, backlinks are good for SEO. However, certain types of links can actually harm your website rankings. Check your backlink profile and see if any spammy or unnatural links point to your website. If there are, you’ll want to contact the website owners of the low-quality sites hosting these links and politely ask for their removal. If they don’t answer you or refuse to remove the link, you can use Google’s Disavow tool as a last resort.  

Also, don’t forget to check Google Search Console for any manual actions or notifications about your links, and disavow any problematic ones. 

Focus on improving your backlink profile by acquiring natural links. Creating more content other websites want to link to is also important to a healthy backlink profile. If you need help with this, why not use our professional Link Building Services to up your backlink game? What’s more, as a Blogger Outreach Agency, we also consult with respected publishers in your business’s niche, who can create and post high-quality content for your brand – complete with quality links, too. 

3. Check Anchor Text Type Ratio 

Anchor text is the linked text that a link uses to display itself – and the type can affect your SEO. Analytics tools can check your anchor texts – Ahrefs is a good one. Ideally, exact match keywords should be kept to less than 10%; anything more could be deemed sketchy by Google. Keep anchor texts branded (your brand’s name), naked (exposed URL), and benign (non-keywords, like “click here”) for best results.

4. IP Address of Backlinks 

Although backlinks are one of the most important factors affecting a website’s SEO position, Google could view many backlinks coming from a single IP address as unnatural and punish your site. An analytics tool like Ahrefs can check this, as can other IP checkers. 

5. The Ratio of Referring Domains 

The ratio of backlinks to domains should be natural. Of course, the number of backlinks is normally higher than referring domains, as some domains might link to your site more than once. 

In comparison, too many coming from a small number of referring domains doesn’t look natural in Google’s eyes (like 1,000 backlinks from 3 domains). 

Tip: Don’t forget – good social media management can drive traffic to your website through quality content and links. Our Paid Social Services can help with this! 

Section 7: How’s Your On-Page SEO? 

Given how off-page tactics can affect your Google website ranking, it’s unsurprising that on-page content holds power, too. With that in mind, here are a few factors you should check to avoid website de-ranking.  

1. Low Quality, Thin Content 

Does your website have a lot of pages with thin content? If so, Google might be unhappy. It’s worth checking any pages with less than 500 words and deciding whether those pages hold enough value for your site. If any of them have acquired backlinks or are important pages, it may be worth keeping them. However, if not, deleting them or updating them with quality content could benefit your site. 

When updating pages with thin content to improve quality and quantity, try to hit at least 1,000 words and inject context; there’s no point in adding word count if it brings zero value. In addition, post new, high-quality content regularly that hits that 1,000 words mark. 

Tip: Struggling to come up with content? Our expert Content Writing Services have got your back! 

2. How’s Your Keyword Usage? 

Over-optimisation and under-optimisation are big problems when trying to rank for keywords. Keyword over-optimisation often means your keyword density is over or equal to 25%. 

Sure, if the keyword you want to rank for isn’t on the page you want to rank, Google won’t rank it – but that doesn’t mean putting keywords in willy-nilly without thought. Instead of plastering keywords all over the place, create content around these keywords and insert them naturally, in context within the content. Including LSI and secondary keywords also helps Google understand the page’s content and topical relevance – which helps with ranking.  

3. Duplicate Content 

It’s not that rare to find duplicate content when you check ranking on Google. Google deems duplicated content as one that appears across or within domains more than once. Sometimes, it’s simply that your content is accidentally duplicated on your website or is too repetitive across your web pages. However, in some cases, other sites may have copied your content and used it as their own. 

Use Grammarly’s Plagiarism Checker or Copyscape to check if another website has scraped your content. Copy and paste your content into these tools, and they’ll confirm if another site is using that content and which sites are guilty. If those sites don’t remove your content, you can report them for copyright infringement via Google’s copyright removal page. This step is crucial, as Google could penalise your site and rank the one copying your content instead – which you don’t want!  

4. Check Your SEO Tactics 

Is your SEO subpar? Answer yes, and your rankings might stagnate without growth – which may cause or resemble ranking drops. 

To fix and even prevent ranking drops and stagnation, keep these points in mind: 

• SEO Is a Constant: You must do SEO work at least monthly and continue consistently over time for results.  
• Content and Links: You need both on your website consistently and logically. 
• Keyword Competition: Your SEO efforts must match the popularity of the keywords you’re trying to rank for. If the keyword competition is too great (or small), it might outweigh your SEO work. 

• Black-Hat SEO: Whether intentional or not, you must avoid these shady tactics to avoid serious Google punishment. Stick to white-hat SEO – always. 

Tip: Our comprehensive SEO Auditing can reveal issues and strategise SEO that works!

Conclusion 

It’s alarming when your Google website ranking drops or remains stagnant. However, it’s not the end of the world. Stay calm and identify the problem, and rectify it ASAP. That way, you can mitigate the loss and get back up the SERPs. 

Need Help Restoring Your Google Website Ranking? 

We work to help sites get their rankings back every day here at Click Intelligence. With two decades of experience working with clients in over 40 industries, our unrivalled, results-driven service and countless client success stories showcase how we’ve achieved a 97% client retention rate – and we can turn your business into another one of our proud tales of success. 

So, if you’re still having trouble with your Google search rankings – whether you’ve diagnosed the issue and tried to fix it or not – we can take the reins and get your website back on the road to SERP success. Get in touch with our SEO Experts today, and let us explain what we can do for your brand. 

• Tip: Our Managed SEO campaigns are bespoke and cover all short and long-term aspects of boosting a business’s SEO and SERP ranking!